Back to Journal

United Pulse

Carrick Is Gone. Pochettino Is In. What Is Manchester United’s Football Plan?

Carrick’s dismissal may be defensible. Pochettino’s appointment may be exciting. Neither decision, by itself, tells supporters what United are building or how the next reset will avoid becoming another expensive change of mind.

Published November 13, 20268 min read

Journal note

Published analysis

This article is written to be read slowly, shared easily, and referenced later when the same football question comes back around.

Freshness check Michael Carrick’s departure and Mauricio Pochettino’s appointment were checked through November 13, 2026. Recheck the new head coach’s start date before later repromotion.

Opening line

Michael Carrick is gone. Mauricio Pochettino is coming in. Manchester United have changed the face in the dugout again. Now the people who chose both coaches must explain what football idea survived the change.

Changing the coach can be necessary. Changing the question every time is not a football plan.

Four commitments, four reversals

MetricCommitment to departureWhat changed
José Mourinho327 daysA recent renewal did not secure continuity
Ole Gunnar Solskjær120 daysA long contract did not settle the football
Erik ten Hag116 daysINEOS reversed a decision it had strengthened
Michael Carrick174 daysA permanent appointment became another reset

The cases are not identical, and the intervals do not prove that any dismissal was wrong. They show how quickly United have repeatedly revised commitments that were meant to express confidence and direction.

Carrick’s departure settles the employment question, not the football question

Manchester United confirmed Carrick’s departure on November 12 after what the club called a disappointing start to the season. The same statement credited him with taking over in January, winning 12 of the remaining 17 league matches and delivering a third-place finish. Both parts belong in the story.

There was a serious case for making the appointment permanent in May. Carrick had changed the mood, produced results and returned United to the Champions League. There was also a serious case for ending it in November. United had fallen into the relegation zone after a run that made patience look less like a strategy and more like somebody repeatedly pressing refresh.

The dismissal can therefore be defensible without becoming a complete explanation. Carrick chose the team, set the tactics and owned his in-game decisions. The players owned their actions. But the leadership chose Carrick, approved the squad priorities and decided which weaknesses could wait.

A coach can deserve to leave. The people who selected him can still deserve scrutiny.

United have described parts of a plan in public

It would be too easy to say INEOS never described a football plan. Jason Wilcox has spoken about a game model, recruitment meetings and matching players to the way United want to play. The club has also described a football structure intended to make decisions less dependent on one manager.

Those statements matter because a proper criticism should test the promise that was actually made. The issue is not whether the phrase “game model” appeared in an interview. The issue is whether the appointments, player profiles and decisions under pressure keep pointing in the same direction.

How should United progress the ball? What does the team do immediately after losing it? Which physical and technical qualities are non-negotiable? How much can a coach adapt the model, and which decisions belong to Wilcox and the recruitment team?

A plan does not become real because everybody in the meeting used the same slide deck. It becomes real when the next difficult decision still follows it.

Ten Hag was the first major test of the new judgement

INEOS reviewed Erik ten Hag’s position after an eighth-place league finish and an FA Cup win. Keeping him was not irrational. He had won two trophies, dealt with injuries and brought young players through. A new football structure could reasonably believe it would give him better support.

United then extended his contract, refreshed the coaching staff and dismissed him 116 days after announcing the extension. Sir Jim Ratcliffe later said retaining Ten Hag had been the wrong decision and explained that the club had struggled to separate the coach’s performance from the organisation around him.

That admission is important. Good leadership must be allowed to correct an error. The harder question is what the review learned before United committed again. If the club was uncertain about how much of the problem belonged to the coach, a longer contract did not solve the uncertainty. It merely gave it headed paper.

The lesson is not “never change your mind.” It is “show what changed your mind, then carry that lesson into the next appointment.”

The pattern reaches beyond one ownership group

Mourinho, Solskjær and Ten Hag worked under different structures and left for different reasons. Treating them as one identical failure would be lazy. Yet each received a renewed commitment and departed before the next anniversary of that commitment: 327 days for Mourinho, 120 for Solskjær and 116 for Ten Hag.

Those numbers do not tell us that the contracts were wrong on the day they were signed. They tell us United kept discovering, very quickly, that confidence in a coach had not answered the deeper football question.

Under INEOS, the same concern also touched the executive structure. Dan Ashworth began work as sporting director in July 2024 and left by mutual agreement that December. Rúben Amorim arrived as head coach after saying he had preferred a summer move, and later reporting described tension over tactics and recruitment.

Different people can make different mistakes. The recurring risk is a club strengthening a commitment before it has settled which football idea the commitment is supposed to protect.

Carrick was backed, but not every football job was covered

Saying Carrick received no backing goes too far. United added Carlos Baleba, Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans to the midfield. Those were significant decisions and real expenditure. The fair question is whether the window covered the jobs the team needed, not whether the receipt was large enough to end the debate.

Reporting around the window still identified concerns at left-back and centre-forward. United cannot fix every weakness in one summer. No serious plan requires a shopping trolley dash every time a supporter spots a gap. But when a role has to wait, the coach and football leadership need a credible way to protect it.

Transfer fees do not play left-back. A big total can show financial backing while the shape of the squad still shows football risk.

Carrick also had room to improve the team he possessed. A connected press, better protection after possession and clearer adjustments did not require a perfect squad. Criticising recruitment cannot complete a player’s defensive run or make a tactical change work. Responsibility belongs at several levels, even when it is not shared equally.

Pochettino inherits more than Carrick’s chair

Manchester United announced on November 13 that Mauricio Pochettino would become head coach from November 18. He brings extensive Premier League experience and a reputation for high-intensity football. His arrival also brings the familiar temptation to treat appointment day as a factory reset.

Appointment day is not a factory reset. Pochettino inherits the players, contracts, physical limitations, role gaps and expectations created before him. He also inherits a football leadership that must decide what it hired him to continue and what it hired him to change.

The welcome interview will tell us what everybody hopes. The first difficult run will tell us who can adapt, who owns recruitment and whether the club’s principles survive contact with reality. United are excellent at unveiling the next answer. The examination usually begins several months later.

Pochettino should be judged fairly on his coaching. Wilcox, Omar Berrada and the owners should be judged on whether his appointment fits a coherent sequence of decisions rather than starting another one.

What a football plan should make visible

Supporters do not need access to private board papers. They need decisions that make sense together. Four visible tests would provide a reasonable standard for the new appointment.

A small set of playing principles that remain recognizable when form drops or the coach changes.
Recruitment that fills defined football roles rather than collecting talent and asking the next manager to solve the arrangement.
Clear decision rights: what the head coach controls, what the football leadership controls and who owns a disagreement.
A review process that explains why the club is changing course and what the next decision will do differently.

The verdict

Carrick’s dismissal may improve Manchester United. Pochettino may coach the squad better. Neither possibility removes the institutional question that Episode 35 raised before the latest change.

INEOS have described a football plan. On the decisions examined here, they have not yet shown a consistent way of delivering it. That is a judgement, not proof that no detailed plan exists inside the club. The evidence can change if the next decisions begin to fit together.

Pochettino deserves a fair chance. The leadership deserves a clear standard. What does United expect him to preserve, what is he allowed to change, and how will recruitment support both?

United have changed the face in the dugout. Now show us what changed in the thinking above it.